Home Page - Gulf in the Media
HomePoliticsEconomy                               Set Gulfinthemedia.com as home page
 Print  Send This Page
Save Listen to this Article
Putin: Holding Fire and Water in One Hand   

Al Hayat - 11 July, 2012
Author: George Semaan

Russia's and China's boycott of the Friends of the Syria meeting in the French capital is striking at many levels. First, the Geneva Accord signed a week ago between the P5 states and representatives from the United Nations, the Arab League, Turkey and Iraq, was not an accord at all. Had it been one, it would not have necessitated the staging of the Paris conference, or its boycotters would have at least attended it, led by Mr. Kofi Annan - whose ‘shameful’ absence could not be excused by Emirati Foreign Minister Sheikh Abdullah Bin Zayed.

In any case, the Syrians were not waiting for the Friends’ conference to learn that what was reached by the Geneva meeting was a stillborn. At this level, the numerous contradicting interpretations issued by the signatories to the agreement a few minutes after it was announced were enough, and it was as though the meeting was never held.

In the meantime, had Russia been concerned about the Syrian people’s interests and not supportive of the regime – as it has been claiming – it should have attended to explain to the Syrians and their “friends” how it was protecting these people’s interests, in the hope it would convince them, or vice versa.

On the other hand, had the American administration been interested in ending the Syrian bloodshed, it should have boycotted the meeting in Geneva and even the one in Paris, instead of settling for Mr. Hillary Clinton’s statements - which he has been repeating for months now.

For their part, the “friends” who attended the Paris conference never stopped calling on President Vladimir Putin to abandon his support for the regime in Damascus and its head, or to maintain some ethics at the level of his foreign policy. But it seems that they have forgotten what Putin does to his opponents, and his imprisonment of dozens of journalists and symbols of the mounting opposition against his regime without any reluctance.

If he showed no mercy toward his rivals on the domestic arena, why would he show mercy toward the Syrian opposition, regardless of its size, scope, high voice and great sacrifices? Three years ago, his government did not hesitate to fragment Georgia, annex Abkhazia and Ossetia and lead them away from the Tbilisi authority. So why would he listen to warnings against Syria’s fragmentation and division?

True, the Paris conference which included the representatives of over 100 states sent a strong message to Damascus, Moscow and Beijing, and set the foundations for possible wide-scale international action outside the context of the United Nations, in case future developments or the obstruction of the deals were to require such a step. This is alarming Russia which is stressing the necessity of seeing the action conducted within the context of the international organization and its charters.

But what is also true is that the Americans and Europeans are settling for calling on Russia to relinquish President Bashar al-Assad’s regime, reiterating that they will head to the Security Council without threatening to use any weapon, however, that would enable them to push the Kremlin to consider changing its position. It is as though they are just standing in front of the Council’s door, while waiting for Moscow to do the honors and open it, bearing in mind that the latter knows deep down inside – just like all those standing behind the regime in Damascus – that this regime cannot stay in power.

In light of this situation, a long time might elapse before the Syrian bloodshed stops. Indeed, this international dialogue of the deaf - or Russian-American dialogue - might take time, which could further complicate the conditions for a settlement. In the meantime, the mounting violence is luring Al-Qaeda and its sisters to an open arena, a thing against which Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari had previously warned.

This is pushing the Syrian crisis towards a series of complications and transforming it into an arena open to all sorts of clashes, interferences and deals. It has become a key part of an international network of relations that is intricate beyond the ability of the Syrian parties to force the international community, especially Moscow and Washington, to change their positions.

Moscow has tried and is still trying to fully control the Syrian card, in order to enhance its position in the dialogue or the conflict with the United States. This is due to the fact that holding the Syrian key is like holding the intricate network of relations and interests throughout the region.

This is why – during his last tour to the region – President Putin tried to strengthen what could be dubbed the “triangle” of Russia’s interests, from Tehran to Tel Aviv-Ramallah and Damascus. He also knows that Syria’s fall in Turkey’s hand would mean NATO besieging his country in a wide crescent extending all the way to the Gulf States – in addition to North Africa – following the changes produced by the Arab spring in Egypt, Libya and Tunisia. Moreover, he is aware of the fact that the fall of this card in Iran’s hand could undermine Russia’s position in the region and weaken its stand vis-à-vis America.

At this level, there is no arguing about the fact that Moscow is placing its relationship with Washington above any other consideration and will use the Syrian card without any hesitation in its dialogue or conflict with it, just as it has done during the last few years by using the Iranian nuclear file. Consequently, its relations with Tehran have suffered, due to the fact that Iran cannot join Moscow’s wing and exit the cloak of Khomeini and the slogan of his revolution “neither Eastern nor Western.”

Putin also realizes that Tehran’s role in the Middle East and Central Asia is no less important than Ankara’s role in this wide area. Moreover, he cannot neglect Turkey’s expansion into the heart of the former Soviet Republics, in addition to the Caucasus and Chechnya among others, which enjoyed ties with the Ottoman Empire, considering that this rapprochement serves NATO.

In the meantime, and through this deployment, Iran is trying to enhance – at least temporarily – its position in the face of the West, whether at the level of dialogue or the conflict. Subsequently, it will be easy for Moscow to agree with it in the region, as long as Tehran needs it as a prominent international supporter in international forums.

This does not mean that Russia has no regard for the Arab positions. Indeed, it took into account the Gulf States’ anger towards its policy in Syria, and has tried and is still trying to find excuses for this policy. True, it relies on Iran and its ability to bother and threaten its neighbors, but what is also true is that it is aware of the size of the losses which might affect it in case it were to overly support Tehran’s policies towards its neighbors.

This could also damage its relations with the Arab countries, in addition to America, Europe and Israel. And since Russia is unable to keep up with the United States at the level of its military expansion and deployment in all the seas – especially the Gulf, the Indian Ocean, the China Sea and the Mediterranean – it is temporarily relying on the Islamic Republic and Syria to confront and obstruct this deployment, as it is unable to build strategic balance with the superpower.

In this context, one must note that throughout the conflict over the Iranian nuclear file, Russia proved to be blatantly opposed to the Islamic Republic’s acquisition of nuclear weapons. And this is a key point of the dispute which provoked in the last few years an open conflict between the two countries.

Consequently, while casting its accusations against Moscow, Tehran did not hesitate to say it was succumbing to the Americans’ wishes. Nonetheless, the Islamic Republic’s acquisition of this weapon will undermine the balance of powers in the region and harm not only the West’s position, but also Russia’s role and interests. Putin is also not oblivious to the fact that relations between Tehran and Washington in the future will eventually be made at the expense of his country’s interests and regional relations. Hence, the Russian dealings with Tehran should be based on the assessment of each step in accordance with an accurate balance.

On the other hand, the currently American administration is being very cautious in dealing with Moscow to avoid angering it or provoking its concerns in regard to sensitive issues such as national security, from the missile shield to NATO’s expansion toward the Islamic Republic. In addition, it is establishing truce with it at the level of the Syrian crisis and avoiding pushing it toward the adoption of a stringent position in regard to the Iranian nuclear file, thus losing its support and allowing Iran to monopolize the Syrian card.

This is due to the fact that the regime change in Damascus and not just Al-Assad’s departure, could - in light of the current map - pressure Tehran, paralyze its influence in Lebanon and threaten its presence in Iraq, as well as lead to Russia’s weakening and threaten its presence and interests in the region.

Now the question is: Will the master of the Kremlin be able to enhance his relations with this triangle to achieve his political dreams and aspirations? This is linked to Russia’s military and economic abilities which do not seem to be sufficient. Indeed, while the relations with Iran and Syria are confronting numerous threats, building relations with Israel while relying on the major bloc of Russian Jewish immigrants will neither reassure Iran, nor appease Tel Aviv’s fears toward Tehran, i.e. Russia’s temporary partner in the confrontation with the United States.

On the other hand, such a step will not help Putin perform a major role in the settlement with the Palestinians, at a time when Hamas’s control over the authority and the Palestine Liberation Organization is as likely as the Muslim Brotherhood’s control in Egypt and elsewhere, and its subsequent favoring the group in any settlement of the Palestinian cause. As to Jordan’s wooing, knowing it is distancing itself from the Syrian crisis, it will fail to impact the relations between Amman and the Gulf capitals that are disgruntled about the Russian position.

Furthermore, Moscow cannot show any hostility toward political Islam in the Arab world, as well as its alliance and the truce it has established in the Islamic Republic. Therefore, in light of these facts, Putin cannot hold fire and water in one hand. So, how long will this Russian triangle last?
 
The Expected Results of Geneva 2
Source : Al Hayat  
Date : 2013-06-06
The United States was late in intervening to end the Syrian crisis, as Secretary of State John Kerry said this week. This tardiness reflects the reality of the situation and...
The Arab Gulf and Hezbollah
Source : Al Hayat  
Date : 2013-06-06
Once again, Hezbollah committed a public mistake by linking the Gulf position towards it to the relationship between the Gulf Cooperation Council states and the United States....
Iran outmanoeuvring US in Syrian proxy war
Source : The Peninsula  
Date : 2013-06-06
Syria's uprising offered the possibility of a strategic defeat of Iran. In this scenario, Iran would be weakened by the collapse of Bashar Assad's regime, its single Arab ally and...
Sweet distribution amid massacre
Source : Arab News  
Date : 2013-06-06
In the south of Lebanon, the seat of the Hezbollah's republic, cookies are being distributed....
What's after Qusayr?
Source : Khaleej Times  
Date : 2013-06-06
The Hezbollah from Lebanon has won the strategic bordering town for Damascus. Now President Bashar Al Assad, without bothering too much about what's going on in his far-flung frontiers, can...
A forum to rethink strategy over Syria
Source : Gulf Today  
Date : 2013-06-06
The world seems to be at a loss how to deal with the crisis in Syria, pitting the regime of President Bashar Al Assad against his people who rose up...
Syrian setback
Source : The Peninsula  
Date : 2013-06-06
One step forward. Two back. That's how the fortunes of Syrian rebels have been oscillating in the past several weeks, despite marshalling all resources. But yesterday they suffered a major...
Peace talks likely in July, says Brahimi
Source : Gulf Today  
Date : 2013-06-06
A conference on ending the fighting in Syria may possibly be held in July, international envoy for Syria Lakhdar Brahimi said after preparatory talks with US and Russian officials on...
A peep into Syria's chemical weapons program
Source : Saudi Gazette  
Date : 2013-06-06
Syria, defeated by Israel in three wars and afraid its arch enemy had gained a nuclear arsenal, began in earnest to build a covert chemical weapons program three decades ago,...
UNESCO reiterates the appeal for the protection of Syria's cultural heritage
Source : Khaleej Times  
Date : 2013-06-06
In the wake of alarming media reports on damage to several historic and religious sites in various regions of Syria, UNESCO expressed grave concern for the safety of Syria's cultural...
A few Americans fighting with rebels
Source : Khaleej Times  
Date : 2013-06-06
Despite media attention surrounding the death of an American woman in Syria, only a few US citizens have joined the ranks of foreigners fighting there to oust President Bashar Al...
Syrian army captures strategic border town of Qusair
Source : Saudi Gazette  
Date : 2013-06-05
Syrian forces and their Hezbollah militant allies seized control on Wednesday of the border town of Qusair, dealing a strategic defeat to rebel fighters battling for two years to overthrow...
Qatar blames Syria for human rights abuses
Source : The Peninsula  
Date : 2013-06-05
Qatar has blamed the Syrian regime for the continued human rights abuses and the tragic human conditions of the Syrian people, who were forced to defend themselves as the regime...
Israel fears S-300 missiles could go to Iran
Source : Kuwait News Agency  
Date : 2013-06-05
Israeli Minister of Strategic Affairs Yuval Steinitz on Tuesday voiced concern that S-300 missiles which Syria is expected to get from Russia could eventually go to Iran....
Hassan Nasrallah Burns!
Source : Al Hayat  
Date : 2013-06-05
Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah committed a big mistake, one which he will not be able to fix no matter how hard he tries, after he became involved in the killing of...
Hezbollah unmasked
Source : Saudi Gazette  
Date : 2013-06-05
There will be those who wonder why the GCC did not declare Hezbollah a terrorist organization long ago. Hezbollah rode high in the opinion of some after it threw back...
Power plays its own game
Source : Gulf Today  
Date : 2013-06-05
Senior Israeli military officers say they are worried over what they see as the widening military intervention in the Syria civil war by Russia, Iran, Hizbollah and Iraq....
Total 410 Results in 25 Pages
  8 
For more news, views and reports about this topic, please subscribe
to GRC website: www.grc.ae
Tue Jun 18, 2013| 09-شعبان-1434هـ
Riyadh hopes for warm ties with Tehran under Rowhani
Deposits at Saudi banks exceed SR 1.3 trillion
Kuwaiti court upholds one-vote decree, scraps assembly
It's a bear stampede in UAE bourses
Port authorities plan to spend SR 3.43 billion on development
Record number of vessels docks at Qatari ports in 2012
Iraq witnesses wave of bomb blasts
DDF records Dh2.7 biilion sales for first five months
Girls primary school attacked in Bahrain
Privatization of landlines soon
Kuwait Amir affirms court's ruling respect
Qatari exports to UK decline by 23 percent
Putin blasts West over arming Syria rebels
GCC to continue to invest heavily in infrastructure
Saudi Arabia to set up blood plasma plant
Bahrain hails historic US ties
    Newspaper Editorials
Rohani's victory: Message of change
A positive step for conservation of Qatar's flora
More>>  
    Opinions
Iran has changed course; now US must do the same
Saudi youth condemn sectarian cries
More>>  
    GCC Press Agencies
Day's main stories from the GCC Press Agencies
    Reports
Iraq Ten Years On
More>>  
    Bank Reports
Saudi Arabia: Interest rate outlook, 2013-15
GCC Markets Monthly - May 2013
More>>  
    GRC Analysis
Building a Strong Saudi-Japan Relationship
Poor Gulf: Inequality and the Lack of Statistics
Whither GCC-US Relations?
    GRC Commentary
On Relations between Rulers and Citizens: The Need for a New Social/Political Contract in the GCC States
Key Issue Facing the Saudi Ruling House.
    GRC Book Review
Beyond Regionalism? Regional Cooperation, Regionalism and Regionalization in the Middle East
India, GCC and the Global Energy Regime: Exploring Interdependence and Outlook for Collaboration.
    GRC Press Release
Gulf Research Center press releases to the media
    GRC Publications
The Uneasy Balance: Potential and Challenges of the West's Relations with the Gulf States
Asia-Gulf Economic Relations in the 21st Century: The Local to Global Transformation
Assessment of the Security Situation in Iran, Iraq, Yemen, Syria and the Arab Gulf States
    GRC Newsletters/Bulletins

Enter your email to get the Newsletter
Go
      
Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Terms & Conditions | About Us |
Weather | Qibla Directions | Hijri Date Conversion Tool
Full Page :total time:0  |   26-- 26 Middle Page :0  --   | Right : 26 - 26--en--sess-enreq-en-coming